“Conceptual Spiral“ is one of John Boyd’s greatest briefs.*
In it, he emphasizes the significance of mismatches.
Mismatches are discrepancies between what we expect and what we observed.
The presence of mismatches sustain and nourish the pursuit of knowledge and innovation.
Identifying them is how we thrive on challenges and contradictions.
Thus they become essential for the continued growth and vitality.
Mismatches represent the very essence of progress in any domain.
They spark curiosity, curiosity leads to inquiry, and inquiry fosters discovery.
If everything were to align with expectations, then there would be no need to reorient.
One of the primary ways mismatches drive progress is by fostering curiosity.
When we encounter anomalies or discrepancies, we investigate their root causes.
This curiosity initiates a cascade of questions and inquiries.
It drives us to explore new avenues, collect more data, and refine our mental models and designs.
In essence, mismatches are as the proverbial "itch" that push us to dig deeper and seek solutions.
Innovation thrives on the presence of mismatches.
As we find discrepancies between solutions and outcomes, we seek to bridge any gaps.
Mismatches lead to paradigm shifts.
We challenge established theories and opening up new vistas of understanding.
Thomas Kuhn's concept of "paradigm shift" exemplifies this process.
Kuhn teaches that anomalies and contradictions occur within existing frameworks.
This leads to the emergence of new paradigms.
In engineering and technology for example, mismatches act as catalysts for continuous improvement.
Engineers and technologists are constantly striving to enhance systems.
Mismatches occur between expected and actual performance.
These serve as valuable feedback that drive innovation.
John Boyd's insight into the role of mismatches remind us of the dynamic and iterative nature of the Universe.
Mismatches are not hindrances or obstacles.
Rather, they are the lifeblood that sustains and nourishes the pursuit of knowledge and innovation.
They drive curiosity, inquiry, innovation, and continuous improvement.
Mismatches ensure that these endeavors remain vibrant and evolving.
Embrace mismatches as opportunities for growth and learning.
This is essential for continued progress; into a future filled with new discoveries and advancements.
*John Boyd delivering Conceptual Spiral:
CS Peirce uses the term "surprise." The logic of abduction (hypothesis) is driven by surprise. That is you act on your best guess (hypothesis) and if the results are surprising - you use this feedback to revise your hypothesis/expectations. This is a pragmatic approach inn which learning is a continuous, closed-loop process of adapting to surprises in order to better tune your expectations and future actions.
The wonderful thing about mismatches is that they show up as “patterns of behavior” that reveal purpose and intent. Learn to see them as the superpower of reorientation is now yours.