Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Reader East of Albuquerque's avatar

So... of late... the professional association of which I was a member has a new president who opted to open this year's annual conference with a "land acknowledgment."

TERRAIN – What surface issue is being used to anchor the conflict? What landscape are they trying to map your attention to?

* Injustice to Native Americans (in this instance, that happened, in complex circumstances in this locale, approximately 150 years ago).

TARGET – Who is being cast as the villain, the problem, the virus in the system? Who is being sanctified as the hero?

* Villain— Conference participants whose ancestors are not BIPOC (BIPOC = black, indigenous, people of color)

* Problem— Injustices to Native Americans in the past on the part of some of these same peoples' ancestors

* Hero—The tribe that held the local real estate at one point in the previous century. (The local history is complex; there was a lot of migration and conflict before Europeans or anyone descended from Europeans ever showed up.)

TONE – What emotion are you being pushed into before you even think?

* Guilt, shame.

TROPES – What recycled storyline is being deployed to make the narrative feel familiar, inevitable, or virtuous?

* Story of the "white" conquest of the indigenous peoples of the American West. Call to be an "aware" and "caring" person.

TACTICS – What actions are being justified once you've accepted the story? What policy, censorship, punishment, or reward is being introduced under moral cover?

* Actions being justified once you've accepted the story? Heaping servings of plenty more of the same!!

* Policy: denigrating "white" people and fetishizing nonwhite people, in this instance, Native Americans

* Censorship: if you object, count on it, you will be labeled a racist and an extremist and you will be canceled with serious consequences for you professionally

* Punishment: Assembled conference participants subjected to masochistic ritual performance without their consent.

* Reward under moral cover: you get to be part of an exclusive group of elite professionals

Expand full comment
Kyle Shepard's avatar

I’ve been thinking about 5T in my own actions too. Where are my biases? Are they being demonstrating in my behaviors or even my thoughts? Reflecting on my challenges throughout a day and determining if I responded well with virtue vs some other form of influence.

5T is fantastic

Expand full comment
9 more comments...

No posts